Shay Laren was the second contestant, and she reported she worked in a boutique before getting into the adult entertainment world. Shay also admitted that, at 20, she'd already been married and divorced, but that was because she grew up on a military base with her stepfather. Shay added her husband used to request that she insert fingers into his rear end while they had sex, which she admitted made her question his sexuality. Shay went on to say she told her husband she wanted a divorce during his second tour of duty in Iraq, and it was mostly because he cheated on her with one of his military colleagues. Shay then took off her top and commented she liked her breasts – which were natural – even though she acknowledged they were so big they hurt her back.
Shay then removed her bottoms as well, explaining she enjoyed being naked and always walked around her house without clothes. For the personality portion of the game, Howard asked Shay which family member she would want to have molest her, and she responded her dad because she'd never met him. Shay then did a scene with Howard from a script she wrote called "When Howard Met Shay," which was a spoof of the orgasm scene in "When Harry Met Sally" for the talent portion of the competition. When it came to the Kielbasa part, Shay got 2.5 inches down her throat while singing "Mary Had a Little Lamb.