As soon as Jamie, the third contestant, walked in, Artie pointed out he could tell she knew "how to get weed." Howard then read a list of Jamie's crimes, which included stealing clothes, prostitution, and robbing a Dunkin' Donuts at gun point.
Despite the final charge, Jamie insisted she didn't have a gun when she robbed the Dunkin' Donuts, but that "the cash register" told the police she was packing heat. Jamie went on to admit she was abandoned by her parents prior to entering her life of crime, and Artie mentioned that, to him, it didn't look like she "ate at Dunkin' Donuts." When Jamie then said a friend of hers suggested she become a prostitute, Artie thought it was, perhaps, "the cash register" again, but she responded it wasn't.
Jamie also revealed she was now working as a drug counselor, and that her boyfriend – who fathered her 3-year-old child – was about to go to prison for a decade for selling drugs.