Howard announced it was time to play a game, "Gay or Not Gay?," where three allegedly men came into the studio and George had to identify which one was gay. The first contestant was a man named Jose, who immediately admitted he got his eyebrows waxed on a regular basis. As Jose talked about his stylist, Howard replied his "Gaydar was going insane," so he thought he'd already picked the gay man. Rich, the second man, said he worked out three times a week, and also carried a man-purse, while the final man, Chad, mentioned he was a bartender, acknowledged he had a lisp, and enjoyed going to the theatre. After listening to all the men, George chose Rich as the gay man, but Chad revealed that he was the homosexual. Chad then revealed he was a Barbara Streisand admirer and was an even bigger theatre fan than he let on during his introduction. Howard then brought in three more men for another round of the game, with the first man, Brad, saying he wasn't a broadcaster despite his deep voice, and James, the next contestant, admitting he "shaved his balls" even though he didn't have a girlfriend. The final man, Teddy, noted he was Artie's assistant, had a girlfriend, and carried a man-purse. After George chose Brad as the gayest man, James stepped forward as the real gay man. Howard then noted he didn't think James was the homosexual either, and James noted that nobody ever suspected his sexual orientation.