A Horse of a Different Color

Howard began with a clip from a documentary about a woman who had sex with one of her horses, with her recalling how the "affair" started. As the tape continued, the woman's boyfriend admitted he was so turned on by watching his girlfriend have sex with the horse that he ended up doing it with the animal as well.

The woman then claimed she enjoyed performing oral sex on the horse, while her boyfriend said he liked being penetrated by the horse, and claimed he could tell the horse was as into it as he was. Howard then played a prank call Benjy made to an old woman, convincing her to have phone sex with him pretending he was a horse. Following the call, Benjy reported he tried getting in touch with the woman on two other occasions, but he was unable to reach her.