When Penthouse Pet, Krista Ayne, made her way into the studio, Howard commented that he couldn't believe how attractive she was. Gary then reminded Howard that Krista had appeared on the show five years ago to be evaluated for Playboy and that Ralph "ripped her to shreds." Gary recalled that, during his evaluation, Ralph claimed that Krista was "a hot club girl," but that her looks weren't good enough for Playboy. After Artie referred to Krista, who's Italian, as "a less hot Dana," Ralph called in to defend the comments he made about her. Ralph explained that, at the time, he felt that Krista needed to lose weight, so he wasn't taking back the remarks he made five years ago. Howard responded, though, that he thought Krista was amazing even when she was evaluated, so he felt Ralph's assessment was wrong.
Krista mentioned that she went to an all-girls catholic high school and that she used to roll up her skirt, which was a part of her uniform, in order "to feel sexy." Krista added that she lost her virginity when she was 15 to a boy with whom she was studying. Krista recalled that she was at the boy's house, and that, after reading a true-or-false question about whether it was okay to give into temptation – Krista explained that the topic she and the boy were covering was religion, so the answer to the question was supposed to be "false" – they looked at each other and decided to do it. However, because the boy's parents wouldn't allow him be alone in his room with Krista without having the door open, she said she had to remove her underwear and keep her skirt on in case they were caught in the act. Artie responded to the story that, if he had the choice, he would've wanted Krista to keep her skirt on while he was having sex with her as well. Krista went on to say that she started experimenting with girls at that time as well, but that she's always preferred men to women.
After insisting that her parents have no problems that she's dating a man who is half black, Krista agreed to get on the Sybian. As Krista was removing her pants, Howard told her to be honest with what she was feeling while on the machine, a requirement she agreed to meet. Gary started Krista's ride on the Sybian at 5 percent, and immediately increased the speed to 20 percent. Krista responded that she could see how some women could get hurt on the Sybian, adding that she was starting to get numb. When Gary changed the speed to 30 percent, Robin pointed out that Krista looked bored. Krista acknowledged that she liked it better as Gary increased the speed, but also said that she was too embarrassed to get fully into the experience. However, after Howard had Gary put an additional attachment on the Sybian and covered up Krista's bottom half with a towel to make her more comfortable, he admitted that the machine wasn't having the desired effect on her. Ralph then called back in and evaluated Krista's Sybian ride as a two, before pointing out that, after seeing her most recent pictures, he still didn't think she was cut out for Playboy.