The guesses for the penis-measuring revelation were unanimous, so no one was surprised when High Pitch said the secret was his. High Pitch remembered that, when he was in his early 20s, he was hanging out with his friend, drinking and getting "stupid high." Eric added that he suggested the two discover who had the bigger penis, which got the scene started. However, Eric claimed that, while all he wanted to do was see whose penis was bigger, his friend took it a step further by kissing and fondling him. Eric also said that his friend's touching him while measuring his penis had such an impact that he ended up "finishing." Despite the incident, Eric swore on his parents' lives that the encounter was the only gay experience of his entire life. Robin then wondered if Eric was still in touch with the friend, but he said he wasn't. After discovering that Eric helped his friend complete the deed as well, Howard reported that it was a good revelation, and led a round of applause in Eric's honor.