JD called in from Hedonism and told Howard he already received "some hand action" from the porn star, Shy Love, as well as two other women. Howard replied he didn't understand why JD had already had his session with the women, explaining JD was supposed to do it on the air. Shy then got on the phone and reported JD lasted much longer than the 17 seconds she figured he would, while adding his penis wasn't "that small" either. After Howard convinced the girls to perform their work again, JD acknowledged he was having trouble getting erect because the four of them were outside and he was uncomfortable. Howard then told JD and the women to go into their room, and call back so he could hear the girls relieve JD. After an in-studio discussion about taking a woman's virginity, Doug Goodstein, the producer of the JD segment, called in from Hedonism. Doug claimed he was never told that the girls were supposed to pleasure JD on the air, even though Gary assured Howard he made it clear the bit was to be broadcasted. As Doug tried to explain his position further, Howard responded that he didn't know why Doug and his wife were even at Hedonism before ending the call. JD then called back in and insisted he didn't know that his time with the women was meant to take place on the air either. JD went on to say he was now with Shy and a new girl, Annie Cruz – better known as the woman who "squirted" in Gary's eye while demonstrating a sex toy earlier this year – and they were all sitting on a chair. Shy then started describing how she and Annie were using their hands on JD, before handing off the phone to him. However, because Howard couldn't get anyone to talk to him on the other end, he debated whether or not he wanted to end the call. As he was deciding, though, Shy picked up the phone and said she'd try to get JD to be more vocal, but added JD was "losing his wood." Upon hearing this, Howard abandoned the call and said at least Doug and his wife got a free vacation.