The final contestant, Taryn Thomas, mentioned she talks to JD through MySpace and that the two have a lunch date planned for later in the day. When JD came into the studio, Gary said he was upset because he didn't want anyone knowing about his online relationship with Taryn. JD then admitted he had hoped to keep his conversations with Taryn private, before acknowledging, though, that "it was another thing that had to come out."
Howard proceeded to ask Taryn if she thought she'd have sex with JD and she responded, "I will never say never." For the talent portion of the contest, Taryn offered a standup performance – which included the jokes: "What do you call it when six porn stars are in a room and three of them are on their periods and three of them have yeast infections? A wine and cheese party." "How do you brainwash a porn star? You give her an enema." "Do you want to know what an 80-year-old's p*ssy tastes like? It 'Depends.'" – but only Taylor found her act funny. Taryn was then asked what super power she would pick if she could have one and she said she'd choose the ability to "heal anyone."