Howard took a call from a listener named Tom, who claimed he was straight, but added he was having graphic homosexual dreams the past few weeks. Howard responded to the story by saying he never had a gay dream in his life, while Artie pointed out a real heterosexual wouldn't have those types of dreams. Benjy then admitted he had dreams about kissing guys in the past, but could tell, since he was straight, something wasn't right. Benjy also said people do things in dreams that don't make sense, and to illustrate his point, he mentioned he sometimes flies in his dreams as well. Gary came into the studio and announced Will had just admitted to once having sex with his brother in a dream. Artie then acknowledged he had a "gay dream" of his own years ago as well, recalling he attended a Mets game in it.