Alicia, 20, the final contestant, admitted she was nervous about the Hodeo, mostly because she was used to being quiet when having an orgasm. Alicia then noted, if she won, she'd use the prize money to pay for college, while also reporting she has had sex with just two men in her life. As Alicia took off her top and revealed her 36-DD chest, Gary pointed out her breasts were "the opposite of bologna t*ts," and Howard commented her nipples were "double pierced." After Alicia had an orgasm on the Sybian – an orgasm that Gary noted caused her legs to shake – she sang "Take Me Out to the Ballgame," with its original lyrics.
Howard then admitted Alicia's Sybian ride was difficult to judge because it was quiet and took a long time, and gave it a seven, while Artie said he liked the way she rode the machine, and scored her a nine, as did Gary. Fred then commented he found Alicia's performance "a little whiny" before giving her a seven. Artie then gave Alicia's singing performance a six, as did Howard, Fred and Robin, while Gary scored her song a seven.