As the Benjy Horse made its way into the studio for the "Ride the Bucking Benjy" part of the Hodeo, Howard reported Benjy was "really playing up the horse thing," noting he was pulling and biting on his leash while making horse noises. Alicia then got on the Benjy Horse, but lasted for only one second after just one buck. Nickie rode the Benjy Horse next, and lasted the maximum time allowed, 30 seconds, while Tina, the final participant, was able to stay on him for just seven seconds.
Howard then announced the predetermined scoring for the "Bucking Benjy" bit meant Nickie got 10 points, Tina seven and Alicia three. Because of this, Gary announced there was "a clear-cut winner," and the $5,000 went to Nickie. To celebrate her win, Nickie agreed to ride the Sybian again, and had her third loud orgasm of the morning.