The next contestant was Nickie, 21, a dancer who Howard pointed out was missing some teeth. Nickie acknowledged she didn't have all her teeth, and said, if she won the Hodeo, she'd use the $5,000 prize money to correct the problem. As she got undressed for her Sybian ride, Nickie said she thought Tina's performance was "hot," and that she'd have sex with her given the opportunity.
Following an orgasm, Nickie sang her song, "Row, Row, Row Your Boat," as she experienced another loud orgasm thanks to the Sybian. Howard acknowledged hearing Nickie on the Sybian was one of "the sexiest things" he'd ever heard, and gave her a nine, as did Artie, while Robin, Fred and Gary all scored her eights. When it came to the singing portion, Artie, Robin and Howard gave her nines, Fred a seven, and Gary an eight.