Bigfoot came back into the studio to have everyone guess which of three women who were with him was actually his girlfriend. Bigfoot explained he and his girlfriend were living together, and that they'd been dating for two weeks. Howard then said hello to the first woman, Debbie, who commented she couldn't remember how she met Bigfoot, and that he was like "a puppy" who she "loved so much."
Debbie went on to say Bigfoot was an amazing lover, especially because he was willing to "go down" on her even when she was on her period.
The next woman, Charlotte, also claimed she couldn't recall how she was introduced to Bigfoot, but added he was "sweet" and "tasted delicious." Lori, the final contestant, said she met Bigfoot at a bar and referred to him as "hot, sexy and gorgeous."
Following the interviews, Howard went with Debbie as Bigfoot's girlfriend, while Artie chose Lori and Fred picked Charlotte. Lori then stepped forward as Bigfoot's girlfriend, and Artie acknowledged he could tell the first two women were acting. Lori proceeded to assure Howard she wasn't after Bigfoot's football money, and that she instead wanted him to put it toward new clothes and fixing up his car.When Howard said he'd heard people in Bigfoot's town were jealous of his "hot girlfriend," Lori quickly took off her top, explaining her breasts were "wrinkly" after she had children. Lori went on to insist people all over their town were hassling Bigfoot over his football winnings, which Howard admitted he didn't understand given the relatively small amount he won. However, Bigfoot told Howard he came from "a poor town" and that its residents knew about his money because they heard the news on the radio.
As Lori completely stripped, Artie asked her if she was on drugs, but she replied she wasn't. Bigfoot then admitted he wasn't able to last very long when he had sex with Lori, and Howard announced he had a tape of them having sex last night. While she was listening to the clip – which featured Lori moaning – she yelled, "Oh my god, I really was buzzin'."Before they left the studio, Bigfoot reported he liked Lori's kids, although he didn't appreciate the fact that her 14-year-old daughter accused him of stealing two of her CDs. Richie from Howard TV then came into the studio and asked Bigfoot and Lori to kiss in order to prove their relationship, which they readily did.