Andie Valentino told Howard that she worked in a gym before posing for Penthouse and claimed her boobs were real, but no one believed her. Artie then administered a "boob test," reporting that they were "unbelievable, but I guess they're real." Gange said he felt an implant, so JD came in to see for himself, saying, "They're real and I love them." Howard asked Andie about her large meat curtains, so Andie explained that she likes them and plans on leaving them as-is. Howard directed Andie to make out with Jana, and the two obliged. Jana said she liked Andie and would have sex with her afterward in her hotel room. Andie then had to answer the "personality" questions:
Which celebrity would you most like to sleep with?: Brad Pitt.
Reveal a secret you've never told another person: "I want to be with a girl."
What superpower do you want most?: X-ray vision.
Andie then shocked everyone with her talent: playing the violin after sticking the bow in her vagina.
Artie voted for Andie, citing her stunning violin performance, and Fred seconded. Robin voted for Jana because of her drum skills. Howard registered his vote for Kimberly but announced that Fred and Artie's votes were the deciding factor, and Andie had won the $5,000 prize.