Howard welcomed Leticia Cline to the studio and told her that the staff played a trick on her while she was in the greenroom; JD and High Pitch Mike were sent in on missions to get her phone number. Robin bet $50 that JD got her real number, and Howard took the bet, saying Leticia probably gave JD her publicist's number. Gary came in to say that High Pitch Mike didn't really follow the contest to the letter, as he tried to use a method that involved pitching her a show idea.
Howard played a clip of High Pitch Mike pitching his idea to Leticia and yelled at him for not asking her out straight-up like he was supposed to. High Pitch Mike said he was given (mis)direction from a few different people, so he went with the method that he thought would work. Howard then played a clip of JD actually asking Leticia out – and everyone was surprised when she gave him her real number.