Sal came in to show everyone the funny gift Matt the Intern gave him: a "Beer League" DVD. Fred opened his gift, a hoody sweatshirt, which Robin liked so much, she offered to trade her wind chimes for it. Fred accepted and Robin laughed that maybe she'd keep trying to trade up. Richard came in to show his gift, an Affliction motorcycle jacket from Jared Fox, Tim Sabean's right-hand man. Howard was so impressed by Jared's gift, he wondered if Jared was being paid too much.
An intern came in to say Fred was his Secret Santa, and maybe one of the best ones ever – Fred gave him $500 cash in a Barnes & Noble bag. Benjy said he also planned on giving cash to Chris Costa from HowardTV, but he hadn't been able to get to the ATM before the show. The crew wondered why Benjy hadn't gotten the cash beforehand, so Chris said Benjy had told him that he wanted there to be a camera there when they go downstairs to the ATM. Benjy, however, denied this, saying that the camera idea came from HowardTV, not him.