Xica noted she had sex with women on a regular basis after she started "exotic dancing at a gay club," and that her first lesbian experience was with a fellow stripper. Although Xica added that she does like men as well, she admitted she hadn't had sex with one in more than two years. Howard then turned to the personality portion of the contest, asking Xica the following questions, along with Xica answers:
• If you could take a pill that would make you white, would you take it? Xica responded she wouldn't.
• What celebrity has the perfect shade of blackness? Xica said Naomi Campbell.
• What celebrity do you feel represents black people the best? Xica replied Martin Luther King, but added Will Smith and Denzel Washington were also on her list. This led Bintell to call Will "a fag" because he thought he acted "too white."
• Should blacks be given reparations for slavery? Xica said no, explaining that, because she went to college for six years instead of living on the streets, she felt other people should follow her example.
Xica proceeded to perform ballet moves and contort her body as she sang "Amazing Grace" for the talent part of the competition. After Xica was done, Bintell gave her an overall score of 8.5, while King gave her a 7, Robin a 7.5, Gary a 7, Artie an 8 and Fred gave her an 8 as well.