Charlie was the final contestant, and she brought up – in a high-pitched voice which Bintell observed made her "sound white" – that she's been with men and women, with her first lesbian experience occurring when she was 9 years old. Charlie proceeded to call the other contestants "hookerish" before assuring Howard she was "cleaner" than they were. This led to a shouting match between Charlie and the three other women, with insults about the cost of shoes, body hair and makeup on teeth flying.
After Charlie sang a song and told the other women, "F' y'all, I just want to win," King scored her a 9, Bintell a 10, Robin a 10, Artie a 10, Fred a 9 and Gary gave her a 10. Howard then announced that, without even looking at the tallies, Charlie was the winner of the contest, which caused her to start screaming and the other girls to start criticizing Charlie for being "too white" to be crowned Miss Black Howard Stern.