When Dave Attell got to the mic, he noted listening to Benjy was like "watching cum dry on Andy's back" before saying that, upon meeting Shuli, he now knew what he would look like if he ever "got AIDS."
Following some jokes about Yucko the Clown – including one that the Virginia Tech shooter got "more laughs" than his act did – Dave made fun of Artie's weight, noting he'd heard Artie was going to be starring in the Anna Nicole Smith story "as the island she died on."
Dave then said he knew Andy was "between projects: rehab and jail" and that a drink, I Have AIDS, was named after him at Caroline's. Dave proceeded to say he didn't consider Andy a pedophile, but that he knew he "got excited" whenever he heard the words "trick or treat."
As Dave made his way back to his seat, Andy acknowledged he thought his routine was "funny."