Benjy got on the mic and called out Gary, Colin and Sal for their past homosexual experiences before making fun of Lisa's looks and saying he thought Robin was white and not black because she raced cars, went boating, and "knew how to read."
Benjy went on to predict Howard would end up getting married to another young woman years from now, and also talked about his salary as the crowd went silent.
Because of this, Sal asked Howard to turn off Benjy's microphone, but Howard let him continue, even though he still didn't get any laughs for jokes he made about Ronnie the Limo Driver.
After Howard pointed out that Andy "fell asleep" waiting to be roasted by Benjy,
Benjy got to the material he had about him. Benjy then talked about Andy's "biggest hit," which he said was when he "crashed his car into a telephone pole," and Gary insisted he finish up.
As Benjy started to stammer over a joke involving a hamster, Andy finished the joke for him and Benjy went back to his seat to a round of applause.