Howard explained to Blue Iris that she couldn't touch the items in her ass cheeks, but if she correctly identified more items than Bigfoot, she would win $500. Blue Iris guessed the first item was a pen, which was wrong, so it was then placed in Bigfoot's ass. Bigfoot guessed it was a microphone, which was also wrong, and Howard revealed that it was a toothbrush. Bigfoot guessed incorrectly that the next item was a rubber ball.
Blue Iris guessed it was a grape, which was also wrong, and Howard said it was a ping-pong ball.
Blue couldn't guess what the next item (a bar of soap) was, but Bigfoot amused everyone by guessing it was a toy doll. Bigfoot thought the next item (a corn cob) was a cloth, and Blue Iris guessed it was a banana. Howard allowed Blue Iris and Bigfoot to split the $500 prize just for participating, which Artie pointed out, meant that Bigfoot could afford a second car.