Howard started the competition with the pull-up portion; Charlie managed two pull-ups, Renee did four, and Andie won with six. Artie suggested they add a "Blowing Artie" component to the competition, but Howard began the push-up competition instead. Charlie busted out 14 push-ups, Renee matched Charlie's number, and Andie won with a whopping 25.
JD then came in for the final portion of the competition, arm-wrestling. JD readily beat Charlie, and immediately collected his "naked hug" reward. After some struggle and one disqualification, JD also beat Renee. JD then beat Andie, who strangely remarked that JD was "f'ing strong." Howard told Andie that she'd won $1000, and asked her to take a celebratory Sybian ride. Artie offered Andie $150,000 to sleep with him, but she chose the Sybian instead.