Nancy Sirianni, Jackie Martling's ex-wife, stopped by to play a dating game with listeners, and Howard noted that she still looked great. Howard asked if Nancy was ever sickened by Jackie's new paramours, and Nancy admitted that she gets the occasional "twinge," as she still loves Jackie very much. Irish John, contestant #1, thanked Nancy for the chance to date her, said he looked like Jim Breuer, and told her he had their whole date planned already.
Paulie (contestant #2) told Nancy that he was so good at oral sex, he was known as the human Sybian. Nancy then asked Mike (#3) and the rest of the contestants if they had any gay friends, who they were voting for in the presidential election, and if they enjoyed her music. Nancy then asked the guys what their wildest sexual experience was, if they were open to tossing her salad, and how often they masturbated.