Howard pointed over to a sheet in the studio, explaining that the three Pick-A-Penis contestants would stick their penises through holes, and Tabitha would then pick one to star in her next porn movie with her. Tabitha felt the first was really small, the second was about 8 inches, and the third was strange-looking. Tabitha decided that she'd like to have penis #2 in her new movie. Howard then revealed contestant #1, which turned out to be High Pitch Erik. High Pitch owned up, saying, "I have a small cock."