Nick, a 27-year-old luxury car salesman, stopped by to confess that he had a big crush on Robin. Howard told Nick to show Robin his ripped abs, so Nick stripped off his shirt. Robin admitted that Nick had a nice body, but she didn't think he was serious. Nick responded that he made around six figures a year and frequently masturbates to thoughts of Robin. Robin then apologized, saying she was flattered - but not open to dating "another man."
Howard thought Robin's reaction indicated that she was in love with Jim Florentine, but Robin refused to elaborate. Howard reported that Beth saw Robin and Jim holding hands under the table at dinner, so Fred-as-"Jim Florentine" claimed he'd just lost his napkin. Howard speculated that Robin's evening probably ended with sex and professions of love - and that Robin was so turned on, lube was unnecessary.