Emily, the first contestant, came in and Howard remarked that she looked "tight" and a little like Lindsay Lohan. Emily told the crew that she was a nurse, so Richard asked if she wears "short nurse skirts" at work. Emily said she usually works in "labor delivery" and – humoring Richard – always wears short patent leather nurse skirts. Emily then stripped down, and Ralph and Artie split on the issue of her large aureoles (Artie said they made her a "real broad").
Ronnie cited Emily's "crazy" knock-knees and uneven aureoles as potential problems, eventually deciding that she'd fit better in a special edition than as a centerfold. Ralph claimed Emily had "a bit of a butter face," and also didn't think she could make the mag. Richard also noted Emily's uneven breasts, but he disagreed with Ralph, saying her face was her best feature. Richard added that she could use a little work on her ass.