Howard announced that it was time for the crew to pull names for the show's Secret Santa gift exchange and went first, dipping his hand into the stocking and pulling out the name Ken Harris, one of the interns. Robin pulled Keith Fenimore from HowardTV. Gary pulled Ryan Rassmusen from the Tapes Team. Fred pulled Jared Law from HowardTV. Artie pulled Lee Gerowitz from HowardTV. Benjy pulled Fred Norris. Fred laughed, "Don't even bother, Benj." Howard then discovered that he had accidentally pulled two names out of the stocking and put the unlucky second name back in, sorry Ben Barto.