Artie said, "Esther might be the hottest, but she's the least funny...Gun to my head? I think the winner is Whitney." Gary voted for April, but not before echoing Artie's claim that Esther was the hottest. Fred also said Esther was the hottest but voted for April. Robin registered a third vote for April. Benjy voted for April and Howard agreed, though his vote didn't matter at that point and Artie wished he could have gone last so he could have voted for Esther (since it wouldn't affect the outcome) in an attempt to get a date with her. April thanked the crew and collected her prize.