Howard asked Robin if she'd like to play "Who would JD rather hang with," and Robin jumped at the chance. Howard then started in the questions (and clips of JD's answers):
Jared or High Pitch Mike? Robin thought it might be High Pitch Mike, and she was right. In the clip, JD said, "High Pitch Mike, although he's been a little bit of a douche lately."
Jared or John the Stutterer? Robin predicted that JD would pick Jared. JD went with John the Stutterer.
Jared or Crazy Alice? Robin again picked Jared, and she was right; "I don't know...unnnhhh...I guess Jared."
Jared or Double A? Robin incorrectly guessed Double A; "Oh my god...oh man...I guess I'd have to say Jared."