Richard came in as the doctor who delivered Gary and admitted that he dropped baby Gary on his head; "He was a genius when he was born - he came out doing math problems. I thought he was going to be the next Einstein, but I slipped up and dropped him." Gary threatened to sue, so Richard promised to cure him of his retardation (by pushing the "reset button" located on his prostate inside his rectum) instead. Gary didn't want to hear it and insisted he'd rather be retarded and "with Howard" than normal. When Richard asked Gary if he ever had wondered what 9 times 9 was, Gary immediately answered "81!" Richard thought this could only mean that somebody had already pushed his "reset button," but Gary strenuously denied that anyone had stuck anything up there.
Will Murray then came in as "Angelina Jolie," but Gary thought "Angelina" looked too much a like a guy for him. "Angelina" offered to have sex with Gary, but Gary vehemently refused, citing his last appearance, when Benjy fooled him by dressing up as a woman. Fred then came in as "Don Imus" to offer Gary a job on his show for $10 a week, but Gary told him; "You know what...you bluh blay fun of this man...get out here!"