Wayne Hoffman stopped by to dazzle the crew with his "mentalist" abilities, but he wouldn't say whether he was better than other mentalists like David Blane and Criss Angel: "I let my audience decide." Howard brought in three strippers from Rick's Cabaret, and Wayne said he could tell the color of the first two girls' panties without looking – but he wasn't sure about the third. Wayne first looked Lacy in the eyes, wrote something down, and then asked her to take off her pants - revealing a pair of pink panties (and, according to Artie, an "amazing ass").
Wayne then looked the second girl, Brooke, in the eyes, wrote something down, and asked her to take her pants off - which revealed a pair of yellow panties. Wayne did the same routine with the third girl, Pamela, who took off her pants to reveal a pair of black panties. When Wayne was done, Artie began to read what Wayne wrote down: pink, yellow, and – here Howard cut Artie off, saying he saw the grift. Howard then walked the crew through Wayne's scam: