Howard welcomed Jimmy Kimmel, Jeff Probst and Jerry O'Connell to play the Celebrity Superfan Challenge - and picked Jimmy as the probable winner. In the middle of his introductions, Howard discovered that Scott the Engineer had accidentally ran all the guests' mics through the same channel. Howard yelled at Scott for the blunder, leading Jeff to remark that he loved finally being able to see Howard blow up at Scott in person: "[But] I'm with Kimmel. You can't fire him.".
Howard asked Jeff why he recently became a producer of "Survivor," so Jeff explained that Mark Burnett just gave him the title without any role or salary changes. Jeff told the crew that he used to date a former "Survivor" contestant, but it was difficult to maintain a relationship with the show's crazy shooting schedule. Howard then turned to Jimmy and asked how he felt about NBC's late night host shakeup, so Jimmy joked that he wasn't looking forward to being "the fat Jimmy" on late night TV.