Howard also played a clip of JD saying he once dated a girl for a month, but they broke up on his birthday after – in JD's words – she met a cop in the video store where they worked. Howard doubted whether JD really dated the girl for a month, and Robin questioned if JD even slept with her. JD came in to admit that he never slept with the girl - he "backed out" at an awkward, intimate moment.
The crew then tried to guess JD's "magic number:" Howard thought it was 3, but Robin thought it might be more. JD then said it was "7 maybe." No one believed him. Fred also said his magic number was 7 ("8 if you count blowjobs."), but no one – particularly Howard – believed him either. Later, Jon Hein confessed that his number was 2 (including his wife).