Gary came in to question an old story about Benjy using a cookie wrapper as a dental dam when he ate out a stripper, but both Howard and Fred confirmed it (Howard: "He did. I saw it."). Gary also doubted Benjy's claim to have had sex with "hundreds" of women, but Benjy replied that his magic number wasn't that ridiculous and speculated that Howard was probably higher. Howard begged to differ: "10. Then I got married and hit a slump for about 25 years: 11. Then Beth. 12, maybe?"
The crew's critical lens then turned on Jon Hein's claim to have gotten oral from (at least) 34 women (a number significantly less than his original claim: "approaching" 80), as everyone doubted that girls would line up to service him. Howard predicted that "By Monday, the number will be down even more." Robin asked how Jon talked girls into doing it, but Artie cut in, speculating that it was just a simple "Do you have the time?"