Howard introduced the first contestant, Ralph, who described his ideal date as dinner and a helicopter ride. Howard asked Ralph what he would do if he went down on Cindy only to find she was really stinky, and Ralph replied that he'd try to convince her to join him in the shower first. The next contestant, Ryan, said, "I'd just stay down there all day until the smell is gone." The third contestant, Double A, said he'd tell her to "wash that stinky thing, bro."
Ralph told Cindy she should date him because he's an honest, caring person with a good job and no STDs. Ryan countered that he was a great guy with a great head on his shoulders who looked like "a young Jim Florentine." Howard then turned to Double A, who had a lot to say: "They call me Double A. My name stands for Awesome Angelo. You come out with me tonight, I'll show you what that means...If she's as sexual as she claims she is, I'll have her in bed by noon today."