The final contestant, Brian, who wrote "Angry Young Booey" with his friend Michael, told the crew that the song took three days to put together. Brian also said he suffers from Peyronie's disease: "Basically, it means I have a crooked cock...it goes down and to the left." Brian said he's only had sex three times in his entire life and is now using a cream that supposed to straighten his member out. If it doesn't work, his only option is surgery.
Howard then turned to the staff for their votes: Robin, Artie and Benjy voted for "Angry Young Booey." Gary, Fred and Howard voted for "Carmina Booey." To break the tie, Howard turned to the three contestants who didn't get a vote. All three voted for "Carmina Booey." Heather and Ita, a pair of beautiful Becks representatives, then came in to present Matt with the $5,000 prize.