Howard welcomed the Baby Booey Song Parody Contest finalists to the studio and turned first to Matt, who wrote "Carmina Booey" and said he worked in engineering and production. The next contestant Yioryos, who wrote "Baba Blues Brothers," told the crew he worked in foreign relations in DC. Howard asked if "foreign relations" meant FBI or CIA, but Yioryos didn't want to say: "Let's just leave it at that." Yioryos said his girlfriend was in the green room, so Gary brought her in, and Howard was amazed: "Most guys who write Baba Booey songs don't have girlfriends...She's hot!"
The third contestant, Josh, who wrote "Law & Booey," said he came up with the song in a couple hours. The next contestant (and former Robin song parody contest winner), Ham Hands Bill, who wrote "Grab My Cock at the Ball Parts," confessed that he hasn't been laid since his ex moved to Miami a few months ago – and then performed his song live! Bill also admitted that he needed the $5,000 badly: he had recently bet his life savings that Roger Federer would win this year's Wimbledon (he didn't).