Howard noted that Steve Langford "got into a thing" with Jackie over the Joke Man's refusal to judge a "Biggest Loser" contest with Pete Best and Brian Dunkleman. Robin laughed: "[Jackie's] never had a sense of humor." Howard agreed and played the clip of Steve asking Jackie about it. In the clip, Jackie said "I wasn't insulted," but when Steve continued to question him, Jackie blew up: "STOP! You're a nice guy, but you're a total f'ing dork...you're a piece of shit, Steven. You're a piece of shit!"
Howard asked the guys if it was a jerk move to approach Jackie, as it wasn't like he'd fired Jackie – Jackie left on his own. Artie said he understood why Jackie might be upset, but "he should have a better sense of humor about it...whenever I'm sensitive on the show, I feel like a hypocrite." Howard said Jackie's anger carried over onto Jackie's Joke Hunt and then played a clip of Jackie ripping on Steve, which ended: "I don't ever want to speak with him again. Ever.