Howard welcomed three women to the studio and announced that the crew would have to guess which one Artie's slept with. Howard was taken with all of the contestants: "Whoever it is, Artie's a lucky man."
Howard asked Denise #3 how long ago she'd slept with Artie, and she reported that she'd been with him a couple years ago when he was "huge" - and the sex was...great. Denise #1 claimed she'd met Artie at a party through a photographer friend, and Denise #2 said she met Artie at a "low point, but he was a good part of it." Howard asked Denise #2 what she meant by a low point, so she explained she met Artie in Cancun while she was in the midst of separating from her husband. Howard doubted Denise #2's story, as Artie's not known to like hot weather. Robin asked what Artie's favorite drink was. Denise #2 said tequila, Denise #3 said a gin and tonic, and Denise #1 couldn't recall. Howard and the crew continued to investigate and explore the girl's stories/accounts before making their decision.