Howard asked if Natalee was scared that the auction winner might have a large penis, and she confessed that she was both scared and excited by the idea. Lisa G came in to question Natalee's virginity, as Natalee appeared to be too "sensual" and "sexual," so Dennis asked Lisa how old she was when she lost her virginity. Lisa said she was under 20 years-old at the time: "It wasn't very romantic." Lisa added that if she had the chance, she'd have auctioned her virginity off just like Natalee.
JD came in to say he wanted to make Natalee an offer, but needed to see the goods first. Natalee flat-out refused to get naked – though she did stand up and spin around – and Dennis speculated that she was too much of a "high-tech piece of machinery" for JD. Howard wondered if Artie would like to make an offer, but, surprisingly declined, stating that there was a certain woman who might have a problem with that: "If I were single..." The gang was surprised by the news that Artie was not single but Artie refused to provide further details.