The second contestant, Stacey, impressed Artie: "Why even bother with the evaluation? Just send her to Playboy...can a gay guy in the room tell me what kind of shoes she's wearing?" Ralph answered that she was wearing stripper heels. Howard told Stacey she was definitely a "hardbody" and looked like Paris Hilton. Stacey said she gets that a lot: "Especially when I have my shades on." Artie thought there might be other reasons: "Are you as dumb as a rock?"
Ham Hands tried to persuade Stacey to disrobe further: "Will you pull down your bottom a little bit so Howard can see? Sometimes a picture can make a difference...turn around one more time please. And bend over...I would say yes." Lou didn't like Stacey any better than Aisha: "I think she's too tall. Too lanky. Too thin. The legs are too thin...I'm very particular." Ralph agreed: "She's a 10 in a strip club...maybe a nosejob would get you [there]."
Ham Hands had a question for Stacy: "Has your boyfriend ever bukkake'd your face?" Stacy replied, "Of course," but had no answer to Ham Hands' next question: "Was your mouth open?"
Howard then promised both girls that he'd pass their photos along to Playboy.