A caller wanted to play a game, so Howard gave him the chance to win $500 in the Wendy the Retard/Bigfoot Horror Game. Howard explained that Sal played Bigfoot a few clips of Wendy the Retard describing a variety of horror films and asked Bigfoot to guess the title of the film she was talking about. Howard told the caller he'd have to guess if Bigfoot answered correctly or not – 3 out 5 takes the $500 prize.
The caller bet against Bigfoot every time. The films Wendy described, followed by Bigfoot's answer and the point tally are as follows: The Exorcist. "Oh, Exorcist." Strike one. The Howling. "Werewolf movie it is. Teen Wolf?" Point one. Child's Play. "I don't have the foggiest idea...all I can think of is 'Little House on the Prairie.'" Point two. Halloween. "Mike Myers it is...Halloween." Strike two.
Howard ended the game early and gave the caller the $500 prize: "The whole game is stupid."