Robin voted for Jalena: "Just because she had the big natural breasts."
Gary went with Sabrina: "She's the whole package. Loves anal, licks ass, pretty face." After first asking all the girls to turn around, Fred agreed: "There's nothing sexier than woman who is topless struggling with a keyboard."
Sabrina swept the rest of the votes from Benjy, Ronnie (who called her the "definition of smoking hot") and JD, who voted for her "despite being a Nickleback fan."
Despite her loss, Jelena then rode the Sybian as the other girls kissed her.