Howard gave each contestant a pen and pad of paper and repeated the rules: he plays a hit from the 80's and they have to write down the song's title and artist. If Neil lost, the curtain--behind which a naked Shayna was standing--would be raised.
1. Neil knew the first song was the Pet Shop Boys' "What Have I Done to Deserve This?" Gary knew the artist, but blew the title: "What Am I Gonna Do?"
2. Both contestants knew the second song was The Cars' "You Might Think."
3. Both Gary and Neil knew the third song was by Whitesnake but neither knew the title: "Is This Love."
4. Neil beat the Booey by knowing that Linda Ronstadt's "Somewhere Out There" was actually a duet with James Ingram.
Neil was elated: "I beat the f'ing Booey, baby!"
Howard still wanted to see Shayna's reconstructed nipple, so he let her play 30 seconds of her music in exchange for a peek: "Wow. So that's the nip, huh? And they make it outta--they make it outta--where's the leg scar? You look good."
Later Howard complained: "She was the most annoying woman."
Gary apologized for the loss: "My memory's not as sharp as it was 5 years ago...I feel myself slipping...I've been getting progressively worse at the game."