Amber then introduced Carmella, a 35-year-old Filipino and "a self-proclaimed sexy nerd who loves dogs." JD started well: "What does sexy nerd entail?"
But when Carmella said she was a punk rocker in high school, JD asked: "Like the Sex Pistols or whatever?"
JD bombed again when Carmella asked if he read: "Not so much. My nerdiness pretty much entails fantasy baseball and video games."
Robin thought JD was showing improvement: "That was better." JD credited Carmella: "She gave back! She returned the conversation."