Howard turned to his judges, and Gary cast the first vote for Kacey: "I am fascinated by the trainwreck that is Kacey." Fred did the same: "Puffy pussy, she was pregnant by Charlie [maybe], she's got tiger blood, she showed concern for him. she bangs her dentist--she's got a very sexy barter system--she [once] did a fat guy hardcore, and she was actually jealous of Capri and Melanie." Ronnie also cast his vote for Kacey: "My vote is with the crazy girl." JD registered the first vote for Capri: "Capri is the hottest chick with the hottest ass...I'm already following her on Twitter." This prompted Fred-as-JD to ask, "Will you suck on a piece of plastic for me Capri?" Benjy voted for Kacey: "You have the Charlie Sheen attitude." Given Kacey's 4-1 lead, Robin and Howard's votes didn't matter, so Howard announced Kacey as the winner, netting her a $10,000 prize. Capri, the runner-up, took home a flat screen TV.