Howard ruled out Jimmy and Erica: "They don't look like such a mismatch...Jimmy's in pretty good shape, so he looks younger. They look plausible." Robin agreed that only Jim and Araceli contended with Gary and Danielle: "Even though there's just a 17-year difference, it looks greater." So Howard crowned Gary and Danielle the victors: "Gary sounds like he's half in the grave and he looks it." Only Ronnie disagreed: "I'm going with number two. Gary looks too happy."