Howard welcomed song parodists Eli Braden, Little Mikey, and Psych to play some of their Robin-themed Christmas Songs live. Eli started, singing "I'm Dreaming of Those Brown Titties" to the tune of "White Christmas." Little Mikey sang "Dropping Loads in Your Vagine or Your Rear" to the tune of "It's the Most Wonderful Time of the Year." And Psych sang "Topless Topless Topless" to the tune of "Knocking on Heaven's Door." No winner was declared.