Nikki's talent was singing, but she was so overcome with passion during her turn that she lost track of her song completely. (In all fairness to her, it was while she was having an orgasm.)
Jokester Raven then hopped on the Sybian and rattled off some jokes she memorized from the Internet: "Sex is like a misdemeanor; the more I miss it, the meaner I get." Raven then came loudly, and with pretty good timing.
Finally, Amy mounted the Sybian with her violin in hand. She then played a passionate interpretation of "Mary Had a Little Lamb" as she rode to such an intense climax that something squirted out of her on the way there. (Cue the painful flashback for Baba Booey.)
The judges deliberated for awhile after all this, before coming up with a tie: two points for Nikki, two for Raven, and only one for Amy. Talent expert Ronnie Mund was brought in to break the tie, naturally, and his decision crowned the winner of the Sybian Talent Contest:
The beautiful (and funny) Raven Bay.