The Secret Santa Dilemma

Howard started the show announcing that his gift for Lori the intern was an easy choice, but Robin said she had a much harder time after pulling Howard's name from the secret Santa hat – even though she only had one gift to buy, she had the most difficult task of anyone. No one argued her point. Artie then claimed he had a relatively easy time shopping for the right gift for Benjy; he heard what Benjy wanted through a "clandestine" conversation.